Corresponding author

Walter Metzner

Max Planck Institute for Solid State Research


Holder, T.; Metzner, W.
Incommensurate nematic fluctuations in two-dimensional metals
Altshuler, B.L.; Ioffe, L.B.; Millis, A.J.
Critical behavior of the T = 0 2kF density-wave phase transition in a two-dimensional Fermi liquid
Holder, T; Metzner, W.
Non-Fermi liquid behavior at the onset of incommensurate 2kF charge- or spin-density wave order in two dimensions

Department "Quantum Many-Body Theory"

Non-Fermi liquid behavior in two-dimensional metals at the onset of incommensurate density wave order


T. Holder and W. Metzner


Quantum Many-Body Theory (Walter Metzner)

Quantum critical fluctuations at the onset of incommensurate 2kF charge or spin density wave order strongly affect single-particle excitations in two-dimensional metals. The case of a single pair of hot spots at high symmetry positions on the Fermi surface needs to be distinguished from the case of two hot spot pairs. The energy dependence of the single-particle decay rate at the hot spots obeys non-Fermi liquid power laws, with an exponent 2/3 in the case of a single hot spot pair, and exponent one for two hot spot pairs – in leading order perturbation theory. The prefactors of the linear behavior obtained in the latter case exhibit a pronounced particle-hole asymmetry.

Charge and spin correlations in metals are singular at wave vectors that connect points on the Fermi surface with antiparallel Fermi velocities. The singularity is caused by an enhanced phase space for low-energy particle-hole excitations near such wave vectors. It leads, among other effects, to the Kohn anomaly in phonon spectra and to the RKKY interaction between magnetic impurities in metals. For isotropic Fermi surfaces the singularity is located at wave vectors with modulus 2kF, where kF is the radius of the Fermi surface. In inversion symmetric crystalline solids, singular wave vectors are given by the condition ε(Q+G)/2 = 0, where εk is the single-particle excitation energy, and G is a reciprocal lattice vector. This is the lattice generalization of the condition |Q| = 2kF for isotropic systems. Hence, wave vectors satisfying that condition are referred to as 2kF vectors.

2kF singularities are stronger in systems with reduced dimensionality. Charge and spin correlations in low dimensional systems are often peaked at 2kF vectors, such that they are privileged wave vectors for charge and spin density wave instabilities. 2kF instabilities are ubiquitous in (quasi) one-dimensional electron systems. 2kF instabilities also play an important role in two-dimensional systems. In particular, the ground state of the two-dimensional Hubbard model, the most intensively studied model for cuprate high temperature superconductors, exhibits a spin density wave instability at a 2kF vector, at least at weak coupling. Furthermore, d-wave bond charge order triggered by antiferromagnetic fluctuations in models for cuprate superconductors occurs preferably at kF vectors [1].

Here we discuss consequences of quantum criticality at the onset of incommensurate 2kF charge or spin density wave order in the ground state, in cases where the phase transition (e.g., as a function of electron density) is continuous. The momentum and energy dependences of the 2kF density fluctuation propagator differs strongly from that for generic incommensurate wave vectors, and also from the one for commensurate (π,π) charge or spin density wave instabilities, for which quantum critical properties have been extensively studied in the past. The quantum critical behavior at 2kF density wave transitions in two dimensional metals was addressed already by Altshuler et al. [2], who computed several properties for the case that the 2kF vector is half a reciprocal lattice vector. For incommensurate 2kF vectors, Altshuler et al. found strong infrared divergencies and concluded that fluctuations destroy the quantum critical point (QCP), such that the phase transition is ultimately discontinuous.

Non-Fermi liquid behavior

We have analyzed the influence of incommensurate 2kF quantum critical fluctuations on single-particle excitations by computing the electronic self-energy at 2kF hot spots on the Fermi surface to first order in the fluctuation propagator [3]. Hot spots are points on the Fermi surface that are connected by the ordering wave vector Q. The momentum and frequency dependence of the self-energy can be measured by angular resolved photoemission spectroscopy. One needs to distinguish the case where the 2kF vector connects only one pair of hot spots from cases where it connects two hot spot pairs (Fig. 1). 2kF instabilities with a single pair of hot spots ±kF occur naturally at high symmetry points, that is, with kF and Q in axial or diagonal direction. That case was considered in Ref. [2], but the self-energy was computed only for a commensurate wave vector. In any case the quasi-particle decay rate obeys non-Fermi liquid power laws as a function of energy.

Fig. 1: Axial 2kF wave vector of the form (Q,0) (left) and 2kF wave vector of the form (π,Q) (right), and the corresponding hot spots on the Fermi surface. Zoom Image
Fig. 1: Axial 2kF wave vector of the form (Q,0) (left) and 2kF wave vector of the form (π,Q) (right), and the corresponding hot spots on the Fermi surface. [less]

To compute the electronic self-energy, one first needs to derive the momentum and energy dependence of the effective interaction (fluctuation propagator) at the QCP. At leading order, the latter is given by the RPA expression D(q,ω) = g [1 – g Π0(q,ω)]–1, where g is the coupling parametrizing the bare interaction in the instability channel, and Π0 is the bare polarization function of the system. The RPA effective interaction and the one-loop self-energy are not affected qualitatively by details such as the spin structure and form factors (d-wave, etc.) in Π0(q,ω). Finite renormalizations from non-critical fluctuations could be incorporated by a renormalized coupling and a reduced quasi-particle weight. Density wave instabilities are driven by the particle-hole channel such that the RPA is a suitable starting point for the analysis. At the onset of density wave order, g Π0(Q,0) is equal to one such that the effective interaction diverges. The momentum and energy dependence of D(q,ω) at that point is obtained by expanding Π0(q,ω) for q near Q and small energies ω. Here the kF-singularity comes into play. If Q is a 2kF-vector, Π0(q,ω) and hence D(q,ω) exhibit a peculiar square root singularity at q = Q and ω = 0.

Fig. 2: Decay rate of single-particle excitations at hot spots as a function of the excitation energy for the case of two hot-spot pairs. Zoom Image
Fig. 2: Decay rate of single-particle excitations at hot spots as a function of the excitation energy for the case of two hot-spot pairs. [less]

Non-Fermi liquid behavior of electronic excitations near the hot spots of the Fermi surface emerges already from the self-energy computed to first order in D(q,ω). The asymptotic low-energy behavior can be computed analytically. For the case of a single hot-spot pair at high symmetry points, we have obtained a single-particle decay rate of the form C|ε|2/3 at low excitation energies ε, where C is a constant. In case of two hot-spot pairs, the single-particle decay rate scales as C±|ε|, with distinct constants C+ and C for positive and negative excitation energies, respectively. It is thus linear in energy, with a pronounced particle-hole asymmetry (Fig. 2). Hence, in both cases there are no Fermi liquid quasi-particles at the hot spots.

For momenta away from the hot spots, the self-energy obeys Fermi liquid behavior in the low energy limit. Close to the hot spots, there is a crossover between the non-Fermi liquid power-laws at intermediate energies, and Fermi liquid behavior at very low energies. We have computed the self-energy only to one-loop order. This suffices to detect the breakdown of Fermi liquid theory, but higher orders may modify the power-laws. Higher order terms may also destroy the QCP at low energy scales, and replace it by a first order transition [2], or trigger another instability such as pairing.

In future work one should analyze higher order contributions in a suitable renormalization group framework. It will also be very interesting to extend the present analysis to the quantum critical regime at finite temperature, study transport properties, and relate the results to correlated electron compounds with 2kF instabilities. Cuprates are natural candidates, but putative 2kF QCPs seem to be suppressed by superconductivity in those compounds. Nevertheless, the strange metal behavior in the normal phase might be caused at least partially by quantum critical fluctuations related to a closeby 2kF instability. Quasi-two-dimensional incommensurate spin density wave order has recently been observed in nickel oxide heterostructures. Exploiting the various options to manipulate oxide heterostructures, one should be able to tune such systems to a QCP.

Go to Editor View
loading content